Juvenile... justice?
Who would have thunk it... people are actually talking about the failure of punishment and incapacitation as a means for making kids better citizens. I suppose this has been something known by mothers whose children don't respond to long time-outs without an insightful discussion into the offending behavior and reasons why it was inappropriate. Well, it looks like California could certainly use a little help from a Super Nanny.
If the Division of Juvenile Justice had the assistance of such a pal on its staff, they would learn that, among other things, treating children who commit crimes like adults who commit crimes will generally teach these children to become adults who also commit crimes. On the other hand, I'm sure the Super Nanny would instruct, if you teach a child who does bad things that they bad things will not be tolerated but the child still has an intrinsic value to society despite some mistakes, the child will respond in kind.
In the youth facilities, education, mental health care and counseling are often neglected because the correctional officers would rather put the kids on 23 hour lockdown to avoid the eruption of gang violence inside the facility. It happens. Gang violence happens, and is perpetuated by the horrid conditions these kids must endure because they committed a crime. In other places, like Missouri, the juvenile facilities that look like prisons are no more. Instead, kids stay in small houses and go to school and learn how their mistakes should not be repeated, not just why. In Missouri, when kids do something wrong, and have to atone for their acts, they go to training schools whose mandate makes the care and guidance of the kids an educational endeavor, rather than a punitive one.
The Nation wrote about the failure of the DJJ in California just a few days ago, right here. The Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice is also releasing a report about the declining youth crime and incarceration rates in California. It will be released here, and is a pretty decent read.
If the Division of Juvenile Justice had the assistance of such a pal on its staff, they would learn that, among other things, treating children who commit crimes like adults who commit crimes will generally teach these children to become adults who also commit crimes. On the other hand, I'm sure the Super Nanny would instruct, if you teach a child who does bad things that they bad things will not be tolerated but the child still has an intrinsic value to society despite some mistakes, the child will respond in kind.
In the youth facilities, education, mental health care and counseling are often neglected because the correctional officers would rather put the kids on 23 hour lockdown to avoid the eruption of gang violence inside the facility. It happens. Gang violence happens, and is perpetuated by the horrid conditions these kids must endure because they committed a crime. In other places, like Missouri, the juvenile facilities that look like prisons are no more. Instead, kids stay in small houses and go to school and learn how their mistakes should not be repeated, not just why. In Missouri, when kids do something wrong, and have to atone for their acts, they go to training schools whose mandate makes the care and guidance of the kids an educational endeavor, rather than a punitive one.
The Nation wrote about the failure of the DJJ in California just a few days ago, right here. The Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice is also releasing a report about the declining youth crime and incarceration rates in California. It will be released here, and is a pretty decent read.

